Head-to-head comparison
Paddle vs Recurly
At-a-glance comparison
Paddle ↗
Paddle takes a unique approach to subscription billing by acting as a merchant of record, handling not just billing but also payments, tax compliance, and fraud prevention. This all-in-one model…
See pricing details
- ✓ Complete merchant of record solution - handle payments, tax, and compliance
- ✓ Eliminates complexity of global tax compliance (VAT, sales tax, GST)
- ✓ Conversion-optimized checkout with localized payment methods
Recurly ↗
Recurly is an enterprise-grade subscription management platform built to handle the most complex billing scenarios while maintaining ease of use. The platform excels at revenue recovery and…
See pricing details
- ✓ Exceptional revenue recovery rates through sophisticated algorithms
- ✓ Handles extremely complex subscription and pricing models
- ✓ Strong financial reporting and revenue recognition capabilities
Where each product pulls ahead
These are the distinctive advantages that matter most in this comparison.
Paddle advantages
- ✓ Teams should choose Paddle when: SaaS startups selling digital products globally Software vendors wanting to avoid tax compliance complexity Indie developers and small teams with limited resources
Recurly advantages
- ✓ Teams should choose Recurly when: Enterprise businesses with complex subscription requirements Companies prioritizing revenue recovery and optimization Organizations processing high volumes of recurring revenue
Pros & Cons
Paddle
Pros
- + Complete merchant of record solution - handle payments, tax, and compliance
- + Eliminates complexity of global tax compliance (VAT, sales tax, GST)
- + Conversion-optimized checkout with localized payment methods
- + Simple pricing model - no hidden fees or setup costs
- + Fast implementation with minimal technical resources
Cons
- − Higher transaction fees (5% + payment processing) compared to alternatives
- − Less flexibility - Paddle controls the checkout and payment experience
- − Limited customization of billing logic and workflows
- − Customer data ownership is shared with Paddle as merchant of record
- − Advanced subscription features less comprehensive than specialized platforms
- − Revenue recognition tools are basic
- − Limited integration with enterprise financial systems
- − Not ideal for businesses requiring full control over customer relationships
- − Reporting capabilities less advanced than dedicated billing platforms
- − B2B quote-to-cash workflows are limited
Recurly
Pros
- + Exceptional revenue recovery rates through sophisticated algorithms
- + Handles extremely complex subscription and pricing models
- + Strong financial reporting and revenue recognition capabilities
- + Excellent multi-currency and global tax compliance
- + Proven enterprise scalability and reliability
Cons
- − Higher price point compared to some competitors
- − Setup and onboarding can be lengthy for complex implementations
- − UI feels dated compared to newer platforms
- − Limited native integrations compared to some competitors
- − Revenue experimentation features less advanced than specialized tools
- − Customer portal customization more limited than some alternatives
- − Some advanced features require custom development
- − Reporting interface could be more intuitive
Which one tends to fit which buyer?
These are conditional guidelines only — not rankings. Your specific situation determines fit.
- → Choosing between Paddle and Recurly depends on your business priorities and technical requirements. Choose Paddle if you're a software vendor wanting merchant-of-record simplicity and tax compliance handled for you. Choose Recurly if you need more sophisticated subscription management, revenue recovery, and financial operations control.